Esther Spanberger

Day of death: 11/18/2021

Location: Pennsylvania

Hospital: UPMC Hamot

Allowed to see family or patient advocate?: yes_both

Asked to sign DNR: doc-dnr

Asked if vaccinated: yes

Was the victim treated differently as a result of disclosing their vax status?: yes

How victim was treated differently after disclosing vax status:

Yelled at and mocked. Told she wouldn't be in this condition if she had been vaxxed.

Name of Victim: Esther Spanberger

Age: 76 years old

Date of onset of symptoms: 10/22/2021

First sought medical attention: 10/29/2021

Admitted to hospital: 10/29/2021

Treatment received at hospital: Treated poorly

Experience in hospital:

My mother would have to go to the bathroom and was told to just go ahead and go and I will clean you up when I get to it. She was left laying in feces... Once had bed chucks shoved around her privates. Feces was dried and stuck to her along with the bed chucks. Ignored when she asked for water or food. Wasn't allowed to have her TV on, just made to lay alone, cold and isolated.

Medications given: ativan, antibiotics, Azithromycin, anxiety meds, blood thinner, blood pressure meds, dexamethasone, Dilaudid, diuretic, famotidine, fentynal, heparin, Monoclonal antibodies, morphine, midazolam, pain killers, paralytic drugs, propofol, sedatives, Steroids

Was the victim informed about remdesivir's EUA status?: no

Informed of RMV side effects?: no

Was there consent for the use of remdesivir?: no

Date victim was placed on a ventilator: 11/07/2021

Days on a ventilator: : 12 days

Person being interviewed: Dawn Malcolm

Relationship To Victim: Daughter

Pursuing legal action?: would

Engaging in activism: no

Watch & Share The Interview

The Interview with Dawn Malcolm

I believe that my mother was murdered for profit. She lived on S.S. and nothing else mattered.

They killed my mother
Written by  Dawn Malcolm (Daughter)

To Whom It May Concern,

There are things that I am sure I forgot to mention but it breaks my heart every time I have to go over this and think about what they made my mother go through. It is hard to remember some things until later when it just pops into my head. My mother had even told me at one point “that something doesn’t feel right, you need to get me out of here”. In the second picture I shared you can see some of the bruising she suffered. Who knows what happened to her when we were unable to be there with her.

I am writing to you today to discuss the death of my mother, Esther Spanberger.

My mother was diagnosed with “Covid” on October 29th, 2021. I do not believe that she had Covid as she got sick like this almost every single year. As a matter of fact; she was so sick a couple years ago that she broke a rib from coughing so much. I took her the E.R. and they just sent her home with meds and added pain meds. They did NOT offer to hospitalize her at that time. Also, the tests can’t differentiate between the common cold, the flu or Covid.  Anyway, I digress…

When my mother first went to the hospital, she declined the Covid test. They continued to badger her (I wasn’t there nor was my cousin) until she finally said OKAY. She had already said no several times. Needless to say, the test came back positive. At this point they put her on a Bi-pap machine. She was breathing on her own already but may have needed some fluids and oxygen. Nothing more. I told them to take her off of the bi-pap machine and just give her regular oxygen but they refused.

Anyway; They decided to send her to another hospital. We, my cousin & I, tried like crazy to get her sent to a hospital that wasn’t part of UPMC… They said that the hospitals we mentioned weren’t taking patients… without even checking. While at the other hospital ( UPMC Hamot) they kept her on a bi-pap machine until they switched her to a c-pap machine. From the moment she arrived they kept saying that she was going to die and that she wasn’t going to make it… said this in front of her constantly. We asked that she be released as she wanted to go home. They kept saying that it would be AMA and implied we wouldn’t be able to get her in somewhere else if we needed to. They even flat out told us that she wouldn’t be able to survive the trip home. She was on IV fluids. For about 7 to 9 days they would NOT give her a drink of water, food or even a popsicle all of which she asked for all the time. She had no nutrition whatsoever that entire time. I know this because I asked her & the nurses when we were allowed to visit (an hour a day is all we were given). The most they would do was swab her mouth with a small sponge and only when my cousin and I would insist on it. Once she had told me that she had to go to the bathroom. I told the nurse and the nurse’s response was; “Tell her to go ahead & go and I will clean her up when I get to it”.

At some point, early on in her stay there, they gave her “Monoclonal Antibodies”. I was not made aware of this until much later, (also was never made aware of the side effects.) after she was vented. A little information about side effects for this particular medicine…

Monoclonal Antibodies side effects:

Allergic reactions, Chills, Weakness, Diarrhea, Nausea, Vomiting, Rash, Itching, High blood glucose levels, Cough, Constipation, Shortness of breath, Peripheral edema, Headache, Fever, Muscle aches & pains, Decreased appetite, Increased triglyceride levels, Insomnia, Abdominal pain, Back pain, Dizziness, Low blood pressure, Anaphylaxis, Serious infections, Cancer, Serum sickness, Autoimmune thyroiditis, Congestive heart failure, Bleeding, Interstitial lung disease, Hepatitis, Generation of antibodies, Mucositis, Stomatitis, Anemia, Reduced white blood cell counts, Hypothyroidism, Serious infections if combined with steroids, Decreased urine output, Difficult or labored breathing, Irregular breathing, Irregular heartbeat, Lack of or loss of strength, Pain, Runny or stuffy nose, Seizures, Slow or fast heartbeat, Sore throat, Sores/ulcers or white spots on lips or in mouth, Stabbing pain, Sweating, Swelling of the face/feet/fingers or lower legs, Swelling or inflammation of the mouth, Thirst, Trouble breathing, Unusual bleeding or bruising, Unusual tiredness or weakness, Watery or bloody diarrhea, Weight gain, Yellow skin, Difficulty swallowing, Confusion, Increased thirst, Muscle pain & cramps, Open sores (mouth),

This medication can cause: Stomach or bowel perforation… including blockage, Tracheoesophageal fistula… trouble swallowing, choking while eating, trouble breathing or chest pain.

It can also increase the chance of infection, Can cause blood clots or a brain condition called Posterior Reversible Encephalopathy Syndrome (P.R.E.S.). Chest pain, headaches, seizures, drowsiness, confusion and High blood pressure.

Just a little side note: Not only was I not made aware of this medication having been given to my mother but neither was my mother or my cousin until mom was put on the ventilator.

I have also included side effects from machines used on my mother and just 2 of the medications used. Any time a new side effect would pop up they would add another medication which in turn caused other side effects and ultimately ended with my mother’s death.

Bi-pap Machine Side Effects:

Skin irritation, Bloating, Dryness- extremely dry/chapped lips & even nosebleeds, Infectionsmucus drainage may be impaired, antihistamines & decongestants may also aggravate nasal dryness, Nonallergic rhinitis.

Cpap Machine Side Effects:

Aerophagiaeating or swallowing air, Discomfort, Claustrophobia, Mask leak, Dry/stuffy nose or nosebleeds, Skin irritations, Dry mouth, Infections, Lung discomfort, Dizziness, Shortness of breath.

Morphine Side Effects:

Dizziness, Drowsiness, Vomiting, Trouble breathing, Sedation, Dry mouth, Headache, Flushing, Trouble seeing, Stomach pain, Constipation, Nausea, Skin rashes/hives/itching, also overdose symptoms: Swelling, Vomiting, Trouble focusing, Difficulty breathing, Stopped breathing, Low body temperature, Blue skin or nails, Fainting.

They also gave her fentanyl;

More common

  • Black, tarry stools
  • blurred vision
  • chest pain
  • confusion
  • convulsions
  • cough
  • decreased urine
  • difficult or labored breathing
  • dizziness
  • dry mouth
  • fainting
  • fever or chills
  • increased thirst
  • irregular heartbeat
  • lightheadedness
  • loss of appetite
  • lower back or side pain
  • mood changes
  • muscle pain or cramps
  • nausea or vomiting
  • nervousness
  • numbness or tingling in the hands, feet, or lips
  • painful or difficult urination
  • pale skin
  • pounding in the ears
  • rapid breathing
  • sneezing
  • sore throat
  • sunken eyes
  • swelling of the hands, ankles, feet, or lower legs
  • tightness in the chest
  • troubled breathing with exertion
  • ulcers, sores, or white spots in the mouth
  • unusual bleeding or bruising
  • unusual tiredness or weakness
  • wrinkled skin

Less common

  • Abdominal or stomach pain
  • change in walking and balance
  • clumsiness or unsteadiness
  • decreased awareness or responsiveness
  • decreased frequency of urination
  • headache
  • muscle twitching or jerking
  • pounding in the ears
  • rhythmic movement of the muscles
  • seeing, hearing, or feeling things that are not there
  • seizures
  • severe constipation
  • severe sleepiness
  • shakiness in the legs, arms, hands, or feet
  • slow or fast heartbeat
  • thinking abnormalities
  • trembling or shaking of the hands or feet

Get emergency help immediately if any of the following symptoms of overdose occur while taking fentanyl:

Symptoms of overdose

  • Extremely shallow or slow breathing

More common

  • Back pain
  • diarrhea
  • difficulty having a bowel movement (stool)
  • difficulty with moving
  • discouragement
  • feeling sad or empty
  • irritability
  • lack or loss of strength
  • loss of interest or pleasure
  • muscle stiffness
  • pain in the joints
  • sleepiness or unusual drowsiness
  • tiredness
  • trouble concentrating
  • trouble sleeping
  • weight loss

Less common

    • Changes in vision
    • excessive muscle tone
    • feeling of constant movement of self or surroundings
    • feeling of warmth or heat
    • flushing or redness of the skin, especially on the face and neck
    • irritation, pain, or sores at the site of application
    • itching skin
    • muscle tension or tightness
    • rash
    • sensation of spinning
    • sweating


Ventilator Side Effects: 

Infection – lets in bacteria that infect the tiny air sacs in the walls of your lungs. Plus, the tube makes it harder to cough away debris that could irritate your lungs & cause infection… V.A.P. Can get it in addition to other infections. Also, higher risk of sinus infection. 

Lung damage – damages lung tissue, weakening of the diaphragm & all the other muscles involved in drawing a breath.

Acute lung injury, Psychological complications – P.T.S.D., Decreased cardiac output, Unintended respiratory alkalosis, Increased intracranial pressure, Gastric distension, Impairment of hepatic & renal function, Pneumothorax, Bronchopleural fistula, Nosocomial pneumonia, Pulmonary edemabuildup of liquid in your lungs on top of already having pneumonia and… finally – “misadventures” due primarily to lapses of understanding & communications among doctors, nurses and respiratory practitioners.

Hypoxemiatoo little oxygen in your blood, Delirium, Immobility, Vocal cord problems.

My mother suffered so many of these side effects.  She didn’t have these issues until after they started her treatment.

Also, for all the doctors that claim this was the right/correct treatment for my mother… I would like them to be put on a bi-pap or cpap machine, go without food or water for a minimum of 7 days, receive the Monoclonal Antibodies and be made to lay in bed. No other forms of nourishment during this time. No breaks from the machine and no potty breaks. Would be nice to see what their health is like after enduring this kind of treatment.

My mother was also put on a dialysis machine only one day after being put on the ventilator.

The day she passed, when my cousin and I walked in the room they had already taken my mom off the dialysis machine. We do not know why. No explanation was ever given. There was a bag on the machine that was at least ½ to ¾ of the way filled with my mother’s blood. They were trying to get her blood pressure up… How can that be done when so much of her blood was hanging on a machine. They also had her fluids bag disconnected and they claimed that her organs were dehydrated… confused yet??? Me too! Why were her fluids not being given to her?

We had repeatedly asked, right from the start, that they give her hydroxychloroquine or Ivermectin but we were told that was ridiculous or that it wouldn’t work. They wouldn’t even try! I thought our president (President Trump) passed the “Right to Try” act. My mother was not given that right. They kept saying that she was going to die so why would it hurt to try? My thought is because if my mother were to survive, they wouldn’t get the extra money. I know they get money for each patient that tests positive for covid, then for each patient that gets put on a ventilator and again for each patient that dies. This to me is incentive for them to not save patients. I know, they say it is protocol. Well, if your protocol isn’t working doesn’t it make sense to try something different. After all, they took an oath to do no harm and from what I have experienced they are doing plenty of harm. 

There are many things that I have not mentioned, like the fact that when we would go in to see mom, she would have had a bowel movement and wasn’t cleaned up (feces was dried on her). Once they had stuck the throw away bed pads (bed chucks) all up around her private area and just let her lay there in feces. I could NOT find anyone that was willing to do an autopsy on my mother. As soon as the word “covid” was mentioned we were told that they wouldn’t do it. We even called many coroners in surrounding counties… not one was willing to touch her. 

I guess it boils down to this… My mother was not a wealthy person, she lived on social security that she earned working her ass off throughout her life. She was 76yrs old. She was overweight but she was far from lazy. She planted 100s of flowers every year, took care of her own yard (mowing/weed eating) and once in a while helped my aunt & cousin with their yards. She kept a 3-story home spotless. If she needed something she got it and didn’t expect someone else to take care of it for her. She also took care of some feral cats… fed them, got them all spayed/neutered and vaccinated for rabies. She was a good, caring person and at the end was treated like a lab rat. She should not have died the way she did with no dignity or respect. The doctors were very rude and indifferent. 

My mother lost her life because there is a “pandemic” and money to be made. I am not saying that covid doesn’t exist but I am saying that my mother didn’t have it. She was as sick as she had been every year prior. Money was/is the big motive for a covid patient to be diagnosed. I also know that the “covid” test can NOT differentiate between covid, the common cold or the flu. People are being misdiagnosed and therefore they are being treated wrong and like my mother, killed. The all-mighty dollar still carries a lot of weight in this little world of ours.

Please do not disregard this letter. Please feel free to contact me and ask me any questions you may have. 


Dawn Malcolm





This is one of many stories we have documented for our COVID-19 Humanity Betrayal Memory Project, a living archive of individuals harmed by crimes against humanity throughout the pandemic. If you have a story you would like to share, please submit it here. You can browse more documented cases of humanity betrayal below. If you feel this is important, please share this page to your social media pages – and since it will probably be censored from social media, take the extra step of emailing it to your friends and family. Thank you for helping us raise awareness of the terrible ordeal our public health agencies have put these people through, so that we can try to prevent crimes against humanity like these from happening to anyone else.

Filter By Category

Glenn Mahan story – Updated to Murder

Glenn Mahan story – Updated to Murder

Age: 65

Location: OK

Became sick: 02/19/2021

Murdered: 05/15/2023

Glenn Mahan

Joyce’s Story

Joyce’s Story

Age: 78

Location: PA

Became sick: 08/15/2021

First sought care: 08/17/2021

Admitted: 08/17/2021

To: Jefferson Regional

Murdered: 08/31/2021

Nelson L Windsor

Hospital Protocol and Medical Malpractice Murdered My Mom

Hospital Protocol and Medical Malpractice Murdered My Mom

Age: 61

Location: CA

Became sick: 09/02/2021

First sought care: 09/12/2021

Admitted: 09/12/2021

To: Shasta Regional Medical Center

Murdered: 10/26/2021

Vickie Michelle Houser

Karen Jeanne Ward Story

Karen Jeanne Ward Story

Age: 72

Location: MA

Became sick: 12/10/2021

First sought care: 12/19/2021

Admitted: 12/19/2021

To: Winchester Hospital

Murdered: 01/06/2021

Karen Jeanne Ward

Mark H.’s Story

Mark H.’s Story

Age: 46

Location: OH

Became sick: 08/29/2021

First sought care: 09/01/2021

Admitted: 09/06/2021

To: Marietta Memorial Hospital

Murdered: 09/15/2021

Jill Hartshorn

Janet and Chris’s Story

Janet and Chris’s Story

Age: 61

Location: VA

Became sick: 08/10/2021

First sought care: 08/13/2021

Admitted: 08/13/2021

To: Centera Williamsburg

Chris Anderson

Tony’s Torment, Torture, and Demise

Tony’s Torment, Torture, and Demise

Age: 55

Location: FL

Became sick: 08/06/2021

First sought care: 08/15/2021

Admitted: 08/15/2021

To: Orlando Health

Murdered: 09/09/2021

Tony Myers

Robin’s Story 

Robin’s Story 

Age: 63

Location: TX

Became sick: 01/28/2022

First sought care: 01/30/2022

Admitted: 01/30/2022

To: ST David’s Austin

Murdered: 03/01/2022

Joe Bradshaw

Sarah Parker – Deadly corrupt hospital

Sarah Parker – Deadly corrupt hospital

Age: 70

Location: MI

Became sick: 04/22/2021

First sought care: 04/25/2021

Admitted: 05/01/2021

To: Covenant hospital

Murdered: 05/15/2021

LaRae Munk

In Memory of Todd Abbott

In Memory of Todd Abbott

Age: 43

Location: AL

Became sick: 09/01/2021

First sought care: 09/01/2021

Admitted: 09/08/2021

To: UAB West

Murdered: 09/17/2021

Todd Abbott

Maggie’s Worst Nightmare

Maggie’s Worst Nightmare

Age: 56

Location: TX

Became sick: 07/30/2021

First sought care: 08/03/2021

Admitted: 08/05/2021

To: Memorial Herman

Murdered: 09/07/2021

Brian Pilgreen

Eyerly- Death by protocol

Eyerly- Death by protocol

Age: 53

Location: OR

Became sick: 09/17/2021

First sought care: 09/21/2021

Admitted: 09/22/2021

To: Legacy Meridian

Murdered: 10/05/2021

Greg Eyerly

Gwen’s Story

Gwen’s Story

Age: 52

Location: FL

Became sick: 08/17/2021

First sought care: 08/26/2021

Admitted: 08/26/2021

To: Baptist North and Baptist Downtown

Murdered: 09/16/2021

Ronnie Eberhardy

Jill’s Story

Jill’s Story

Age: 50

Location: IL

Became sick: 12/08/2021

First sought care: 12/12/2021

Admitted: 12/12/2021

To: Memorial Hospital (Decatur Memorial Hospital)

Murdered: 01/08/2022

Leon "Buck" Parton

Marsha Morris Story

Marsha Morris Story

Age: 79

Location: NV

Became sick: 10/22/2022

First sought care: 10/23/2022

Admitted: 10/23/2022

To: Centennial Hospital, Las Vegas, NV

Murdered: 11/05/2022

Marsha Morris

My Mother , My best friend: Jen Wishniak’s Story

My Mother , My best friend: Jen Wishniak’s Story

Age: 71

Location: NY

Became sick: 08/21/2021

First sought care: 08/24/2021

Admitted: 08/24/2021

To: Good Samaritan

Murdered: 10/06/2021

Anne Wishniak

Don Truman Taylor Story

Don Truman Taylor Story

Age: 64

Location: TX

Became sick: 01/03/2022

First sought care: 01/10/2022

Admitted: 01/28/2022

To: Medical City Alliance

Murdered: 02/21/2022

Don Truman Taylor

Rob’s Story

Rob’s Story

Age: 57

Location: OH

Became sick: 11/07/2021

First sought care: 11/12/2021

Admitted: 11/15/2021

To: Margaret Mary Community Hospital, Batesville Indiana; Columbus Regional Hospital, Columbus, IN; Select Specialty LTAC Christ Hospital, Cincinnati OH; Christ Hospital ICU Cincinnati, OH

Murdered: 12/24/2021

Robert A. Brack “Rob”

Uriel Javier’s Story

Uriel Javier’s Story

Age: 54

Location: CA

Became sick: 07/08/2021

First sought care: 07/15/2021

Admitted: 07/16/2021

To: Saint John's Providence

Murdered: 08/17/2021

Victor Manuel Javier Ruiz

Hardworking Family Man Killed by Remdesivir Hospital Protocol

Age: 43

James R. Crain Story

James R. Crain Story

Age: 60

Location: IL

Became sick: 06/20/2021

First sought care: 06/23/2021

Admitted: 06/26/2021

To: Good Samaritan Hospital

Murdered: 08/03/2021

James R. Crain

Lendle Dean Stockstill Story

Lendle Dean Stockstill Story

Age: 48

Location: OK

Became sick: 09/11/2021

First sought care: 09/13/2021

Admitted: 09/17/2021

To: SSM health Shawnee Oklahoma

Murdered: 09/28/2021

Lendle Dean Stockstill

Tracie Meyer- How the vaccine changed my life

Tracie Meyer- How the vaccine changed my life

Age: 60

Location: AZ

Became sick: 04/15/2022

First sought care: 04/19/2021

Admitted: 04/19/2021

To: Banner Tucson

Tracie Mayer

Dariann Van Holton

Dariann Van Holton

Age: 48

Location: IA

Became sick: 12/19/2021

First sought care: 12/20/2021

Admitted: 12/28/2021

To: Mercy Westlake

Murdered: 02/28/2022

Darryl Van Holton

These are just a few of the cases archived by our COVID-19 Humanity Betrayal Memory Project, and there are more being reported by survivors and families of victims every day. If you would like to help with this project, please consider becoming part of the Task Citizens Force Against Instutional Capture And Crimes Against Humanity, a FormerFedsGroup Freedom Foundation mission.